Journal of Innovative Agriculture, Volume 8, Issue 2 : 39-46. Doi : 10.37446/jinagri/rsa/8.2.2021.39-46
Research Article

OPEN ACCESS | Published on : 30-Jun-2021

Genotype × Environment interaction studies in lentil under Afghanistan environments

  • Darya Khan Akbarzai
  • Provincial agriculturist, International Center for Agricultural Research in the Dry Areas (ICARDA), Kabul, Afghanistan.
  • Suhilla Nisar
  • Head of Pulse and Legume department, Ministry of Agriculture, Irrigation and Livestock (MAIL), Kabul, Afghanistan.
  • Lina Mohammadi
  • Female Extension Officer, International Center for Agricultural Research in the Dry Areas (ICARDA), Kabul, Afghanistan.


Lentil (Lens culinaris Medik. culinaris) is an important pulse crop causative to nutrition and food security of people in Afghanistan. Genotype by environment interaction (GEI) is one of the major factors restraining the efficiency of any breeding program. This study consisted of two lentil yield trials conducted in alpha design with two or three replicates at three locations for two years (2014-2015 and 2015-2016). Genotypic differences were significant (P<0.05) in all the environments. Genotype × location interactions were found significant (P<0.01) in each year for LIEN-LS and LIEN-SS trials. There were significant genotype × year interactions of crossover type. For LIEN-LS genetic materials, Herat and Mazar formed a mega-environment based on responses in 2015 and 2016. High yielding genotypes with specific adaptation to Mazar and Herat environment were LG16 (FLIP2012-21L) in 2015 and LG24 (FLIP2013-3L) in 2016, whereas LG30 (FLIP2013-20L) was identified as high yielding with specific adaptation to Nangarhar environment during both the years. The high yielding genotypes in 2015 were LG32 (FLIP2013-29L) at Herat, LG16 (FLIP2012-21L) at Mazar and LG30 (FLIP2013-20L) at Nangarhar from LIEN-LS. In 2016, LG12 (FLIP2013-16L) at Herat, LG5 (FLIP2013-3L) at Mazar and LG1 (FLIP2013-20L) at Nangarhar were identified as high yielding genotypes. In 2015-16, SG12 (FLIP 2013-51L) at Herat, SG2 (FLIP2013-59L) at Mazar and SG6 (FLIP2013-66L) at Nangarhar were the top yielding genotypes from LIEN-SS. The identified genotypes from LIEN-LS and LIEN-SS at the two locations (Mazar and Nangarhar) may be used for up-scaling lentil production to support food security in Afghanistan as well as for generating new genotypes using crossing-selection-evaluation cycle.


lentil, genotypes × environment interaction, adaptation, Afghanistan, GGE bi-plot


  • Abo-Hegazy, S.R.E.,  Selim, T. &  Ashrie, A.A.M. (2013). Genotype x environment interaction and stability analysis for yield and its components in lentil. Journal of Plant Breeding and Crop Science, 5, 85-90.

    Akbarzai, D.K., Saharawat, Y., Mohammadi, L., Manan, A.R., Habibi, A., Tavva, S., Nigamananda, S. & Singh, M. (2017). Genotype × Environment Interaction and Identification of High Yielding Wheat Genotypes for Afghanistan. Journal of Experimental Biology and Agricultural Sciences, 5, 225-234.

    Bhatty, R.S. (1988). Composition and quality of lentil (Lens culinaris Medik.). A review - Canadian Inst. Journal of Food Science and Technology, 21, 144–160.

    Christiansen, S., Ryan, J., Singh, M., Ates, S.,  Bahhady, F., Mohamed, K., Youssef, O. & Loss, S.  (2015). Potential legume alternatives to fallow and wheat monoculture for the Mediterranean environments. Crop & Pasture Science, 66, 113–121.

    Dehghani, H., Sabaghpour, S.H. & Sabaghnia, N. (2008). Genotype x environment interaction for grain yield of some lentil genotypes and relationship among univariate stability statistics. Spanish Journal of Agricultural Research, 6, 385-394

    DeLacy, I.H., Basford, K.E., Cooper, M. & Fox. P.N. (1996a). Retrospective analysis of historical data sets from multi-environment trials- Case studies. p. 243–267.M. Cooper and G.L. Hammer (ed): Plant Adaptation and Crop Improvement. CAB Int., Wallingford, UK.

    DeLacy, I.H., Ratnasiri, W.G.A. & Mirzawan, P.D.N. (1996b.) Retrospective analysis of historical data sets from multi-environment trials-Case studies. p. 269–290. In M. Cooper and G.L. Hammer (Eds.) Plant adaptation and crop improvement. CAB Int., Wallingford, UK.

    Eberhart, S.A.& Russell W.A. (1966). Stability parameters for comparing varieties. Crop Science, 6, 36-40.

    Erskine, W., Rihawi, S. & Capper, B.S. (1990). Variation in lentil straw quality. Animal Feed Science and Technology, 28, 61-69.

    FAOSTAT. (2016). Available at  FAO, Rome, Italy. (verified 23 July 2020).

    Finlay, K.W. & Wilkinson G.N. (1963). The analysis of adaptability in plant breeding programme. Journal of Agricultural Research. 14, 742-754. 

    Gauch, H.G. &  Zobel , R.W. (1988). Predictive and postdictive success of statistical Analyses of yield trials. Theoretical and Applied Genetics, 76:1-10.

    Hamdi, A. & Rabeia, B.M.B. (1991). Genetic and environmental variations in seed yield, seed size and cooking quality of lentil. Annals of Agricultural Science, Moshtohor, 29, 51-60.

    Hamdi, A., Somaya, M., Morsy, E. & El-Garreib A. (2002). Genetic andenvironmental variations in seed yield and its components, protein and cooking quality of lentil. Egyptian Journal of Agricultural Research, 80,737-752

    Hamdi, A., Zakia, M., Ezzat, & Shaaban, M. (1995). Evaluation of methods measured variety performance in multi-location testing trails in lentil. Bull. Faculty of Agriculture, Cairo University, 46, 593-608.

    Imtiaz, M., Malhotra, R.S., Singh, M. & Arslan, S. (2013). Identifying High Yielding, Stable Chickpea Genotypes for Spring Sowing: Specific Adaptation to Locations and Sowing Seasons in the Mediterranean Region. Crop Science, 53, 1472-1480. 

    Kaya, Y., Akcura, M. & Taner, S. (2006). GGE-Biplot analysis of multi-environment yield trials in bread wheat. Turkish Journal of Agriculture & Forestry, 30, 325–337. 

    Kempthorne, O. (1952). The Design and Analysis of Experiments. American. Journal of Agricultural Economics, 34, 427–429.

    Lin, C.S.,. Binns, M.R. & Lefkovitch, L.P. (1986). Stability analysis: Where do we stand?. Crop Science, 26, 894–900.

    MAIL. (2014). Available at Statistical information. MAIL, Kabul, Afghanistan.

    Mohammadi L, Saharawat, Y., Akbarzai, D.K., Manan, A.R., Habibi, A., Soofizada, Q., Tavva, S., Swain, N. & Singh, M. (2017). Genotype × Environment Interaction in Chickpea (Cicer Arietinum L.) Under Afghanistan Environments and Identification of High Yielding Genotypes.  Journal of Experimental Biology and Agricultural Sciences, 5, 428-438.

    Ryan, J., Singh, M. & Christiansen, S. (2012). Assessment of long-term barley–legume rotations in a typical Mediterranean agro-ecosystem: grain and straw yields. Agron. Soil Sci, 58, 233–246.

    Sabaghnia, N., Dehghani, H. & Sabaghpour, S.H. (2008). Graphic Analysis of Genotype by Environment Interaction for Lentil Yield in Iran. Agronomy Journal, 100, 760–764.

    Sabaghnia, N., Karimizadeh, R. & Mohammadi, M. (2012). Genotype by environment interaction and stability analysis for grain yield of lentil genotypes. Žemdirbystė=Agriculture, 99, 305–312. 

    Samonte, S.O.P.B., Wilson, L.T.,  McClung, A.M. & Medley,  J.C. (2005). Targeting cultivars onto rice growing environments using AMMI and SREG GGE biplot analyses. Crop Science, 45, 2414–2424.

    Sarker, A. & Singh, M. (2015). Improving breeding efficiency through application of appropriate experimental designs and analysis models: a case of lentil (Lens culinaris Medikus subsp. culinaris) yield trials. Field Crops Research, 179, 26-34.

    Sarker, A., Erskine, W.  & Singh, M. (2003). Regression models for lentil seed and straw yields in Near East. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, 116, 61-72.

    Sarker, A., Singh, M.  & Erskine, W. (2001). Efficiency of spatial methods in yield trials in lentils (lens culinaris ssp. Culinaris). Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge, 137, 427-438.

    Sarker, A., Singh, M., El-Ashkar, F., Erskine, W. & De-Pauw, E. (2007). Approaches to rationalizing selection of test environments for on-farm lentil variety trials in Mediterranean rainfed cropping systems. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research, 58, 335–341.

    Sarker, A., Singh, M., Rajaram, S. & Erskine, W. (2010). Adaptation of Small-seeded Red Lentil (Lens culinaris Medikus subsp. culinaris) to Diverse Environments. Crop Science, 50, 1250–1259.

    Savage, G. P. (1988). The composition and nutritive value of lentils (Lens culinaris). Nutrition Abstracts and Reviews (Series A), 58, 320‑343.

    Sayar, M.S.  & Han, Y.  (2016). Forage yield performance of forage pea (Pisum sativum spp. arvense L.) genotypes and assessments using GGE biplot analysis. Journal of  Agriculture Science and Technology,  18, 1621-1634.

    Selim, T.A.A. (2000). Genotype and environmental effects on seed yield, yield components and seed quality characters in lentil. M. Sc., Thesis. Faculty of Agriculture, Al Azhar Univ, Egypt.

    Summerfield, R.J., Roberts, E.H., Erskine,  W. & Ellis, R.H. (1985). Effects of temperature and photoperiod on flowering in lentils (Lens culinaris Medic.). Annals of Botany, 56, 659–671.

    VSN International. (2015). The Guide to the Genstat Command Language (Release 18), Part 2 Statistics. VSN International, Hemel Hempstead, UK.

    Yan, W. (2011). GGE Biplot vs. AMMI Graphs for Genotype-by-Environment Data Analysis. Journal of the Indian Society of Agricultural Statistics, 65, 181-193.

    Yan, W., Hunt, L.A., Sheng, Q.  & Szlavnics, Z.  (2000). Cultivar evaluation and mega-environment investigation based on GGE biplot. Crop Science, 40, 597–605.

    Yan, W., Kang, M.S., Ma, B., Wood, S. & Cornelius, P.L. (2007). GGE biplots vs. AMMI analysis of genotype-by-environment data. Crop Science, 47, 643-655.